How to test AI models depends on what the model returns. A classifier gets scored against labeled answers. An LLM can word the same answer differently on every run, so it needs graders and repeat trials.
Agents, meanwhile, can pass every single-turn check and still fail the conversation when it loses context between turns.
We test voice and chat agents every day, and the same rules hold from a simple classifier up to a multi-turn agent.
Our verdict up front is to match the test to the output, and never trust a single run. Below are seven methods, an eight-step process, the metrics for each model type, and the tools to run them.
TL;DR: How to Test AI Models
The short version:
-
Choose a held-out test set if your model returns a label or a number. Choose golden datasets, graders, simulations, and red-team runs if it's an LLM or an agent.
-
Choose repeat trials and pass^k if the output varies between runs. Per Anthropic, an agent that passes 75% of single trials passes 3 in a row only about 42% of the time.
-
Choose live scoring if the model is already in production, with the same criteria as your pre-release suite. Turn each production failure into a regression case.
| Model type | What it returns | Tests that apply | Metrics to report |
|---|---|---|---|
| Classification model | A label | Held-out test set, slice checks, drift monitoring | Accuracy, precision, recall, F1 |
| Regression model | A number | Held-out test set, slice checks, drift monitoring | MAE, RMSE, R² |
| LLM | Free-form text | Golden dataset, assertions, LLM-as-a-judge, red teaming | Rubric pass rate, unsupported claim rate, latency |
| AI agent | Tool calls and multi-step actions | Scenario simulation, trajectory grading, regression suite, red teaming | Task completion, tool call success |
| Voice agent | A spoken conversation | Simulated calls with noise and interruptions | Word error rate, P95 latency, interruption handling |
What Is AI Model Testing?
AI model testing is the practice of measuring whether a model's outputs meet criteria you set in advance, before release and while it runs in production. The first split is between traditional ML models and LLMs.
Traditional ML Models
A trained classifier or regression model usually returns the same prediction for the same input once its weights and settings are fixed. You test it by scoring predictions against a labeled test set the model hasn't seen during training.
Three failures come up again and again:
-
Data leakage
-
Weak results on one slice of your data
-
Drift once live inputs change.
Leakage is the hardest of the three to spot, because it makes scores look better. The scikit-learn docs define data leakage as using information "that would not be available at prediction time" when building the model.
The solution is to split first and fit every preprocessing step on the training data only.
Check why the model decides as well as what it decides. Explainability tools like SHAP and LIME show which inputs drove each prediction, so you can catch a model leaning on a feature it shouldn’t use.
LLMs and AI Agents
An LLM can answer one prompt in different words on each run, and many tasks have no single correct string to compare against. So LLM tests pair fixed inputs with graders: code checks, a second model acting as judge, and human reviewers.
Agents call tools and take multi-step actions. You grade the full trajectory along with the final message, which our guide to AI agent evals covers in depth.
Voice agents add an audio pipeline on top. Speech recognition under noise and response latency each need their own test, and so do interruptions.
What You Need Before Testing an AI Model
Have these five things ready:
-
Written success criteria: One sentence per behavior, each with a threshold you can measure.
-
Examples from production: Production logs, support tickets, and bug reports surface failures that invented cases miss.
-
An isolated test environment: Every trial starts from a clean state, with the model version and settings pinned.
-
A baseline: Scores from the version you run today, so a new score means something.
-
An owner for "good": One domain expert labels a sample by hand and settles disputes about pass conditions.
Time required: For an AI agent, our agent evals guide budgets about a day for usable results with the open-source agentevals trajectory evaluator and 2 weeks for custom rubrics. Both estimates change with your stack and criteria.
7 AI Model Testing Methods
Each method catches a different kind of failure, so expect to stack three or four of them.
1. Golden Datasets
What it is: A fixed set of inputs, each with an expected output or a pass condition written beforehand.
How it works: You run the model on every input and score the results. A classifier gets exact-match scoring, and an LLM gets assertions or a rubric. For a traditional ML model, the held-out test set plays this role.
When to use it: First, because every later method needs fixed inputs to compare against.
Anthropic's engineering team writes that "20-50 simple tasks drawn from real failures is a great start." Early on, each change moves scores enough that a small set shows it.
2. Scenario and Simulation Testing
What it is: A simulated user holds a full conversation with your agent, following a script that sets the user's goal and behavior.
How it works: Each scenario names an intent, a persona, and an expected outcome. The simulator plays the user turn by turn, and graders score the transcript once the conversation ends.
When to use it: Any model that holds multi-turn conversations or calls tools.
Start from the requests callers make every day. A library covering your 30 to 50 top user intents, pulled from past call transcripts, is the starting size our voice AI evals guide recommends.
3. Human Review
What it is: People read complete outputs or transcripts and label them against the rubric.
How it works: Reviewers sample outputs, mark each pass or fail, and note the failure type. Those labels become the reference you calibrate model-based graders against, while code checks get validated against the spec.
Case study: Model-based graders can miss whole classes of failures, and only a human pass shows how many.
In a 2026 study of a deployed multi-turn ordering agent, the operational gate flagged none of 100 rounds while human reviewers confirmed 23 distinct defects.
The agent’s LLM judge often described those failures in its free-text notes. But the rubric had no axis to score them, and the gate only checked for hangs and hard assertions, so those notes never reached the release decision.
4. LLM-as-a-Judge
What it is: A second model scores outputs against a rubric you write.
How it works: The judge receives the input, the response, and the rubric, then returns a verdict with its reasoning.
In the MT-bench study, GPT-4 as judge reached over 80% agreement with human preferences on MT-bench and Chatbot Arena, the same level humans reach with each other. At that level, a calibrated judge can take over routine grading and free reviewers for the hard cases.
Where it breaks: That paper also documents position, verbosity, and self-enhancement biases.
Agreement drops further once the task needs domain expertise. In a 2024 study, subject-matter experts in dietetics and mental health agreed with an LLM judge 68% and 64% of the time on overall preference.
Judges in expert domains need expert labels to calibrate against.
When to use it: Subjective qualities such as tone and helpfulness, after you've checked the judge against human labels.
5. Adversarial and Red-Team Tests
What it is: Deliberate attempts to make the model break its rules, including prompt injection, jailbreaks, and data extraction.
How it works: A human or an attacker model sends hostile inputs, and a rubric scores whether the target complied.
Test across turns. Defenses that hold in a short exchange can give way later. In the X-Teaming paper, attack success against a Llama-3-8B-Instruct model fine-tuned on SafeMTData rose from 19.5% at 2 turns to 92.7% at 8.
A suite that stops at two or three turns misses the bulk of that risk.
When to use it: Before launch, then after every prompt change, model swap, or knowledge base update.
6. Regression Testing
What it is: Rerunning your stored test set after every change and comparing the scores with the last run.
How it works: Wire the suite into CI so a prompt edit or model upgrade can't merge while a required test fails. The suite keeps growing from production failures, which the monitoring section covers.
When to use it: As soon as prompts or models change on a schedule. Start with the 15 copyable cases in test prompts.
7. Bias Checks
What it is: Tests for whether quality or outcomes differ across groups of users.
How it works: For a classifier, compute precision and recall per slice, such as region or language, and compare each with the overall figure. For an LLM, send prompt pairs that differ only in one detail, like a name or a dialect. Repeat each pair several times and compare the responses.
When to use it: Any model whose output decides something about a person, like a loan, a job application, or a medical appointment.
Which AI Model Testing Method Should You Start With?
| Your situation | Start with |
|---|---|
| Traditional ML model with labeled data | Held-out test set |
| Output has a fixed format | Golden dataset with assertions |
| The agent holds conversations or calls tools | Scenario simulation |
| Tone or helpfulness matters | LLM-as-a-judge, calibrated by human review |
| The model is user-facing or touches sensitive data | Red-team tests |
| Prompts or models change weekly | Regression testing in CI |
| Outputs decide something about a person | Bias checks |
How to Test AI Models in Eight Steps
These eight steps cover how to test AI models from a written pass condition to a release gate. They apply to any model type, and steps five and six carry extra weight for LLMs and agents.
1. Define Success Criteria
Write what a pass looks like before you write a single test. Name the metric, the threshold, and the failure modes you care about, such as task completion, latency, cost per task, and policy compliance.
Pro tip: If two engineers disagree on whether an output passes, rewrite the criterion until they agree.
2. Build a Test Set From Past Failures
Turn the production examples you gathered into test cases. Start with the set size from method one and grow it as the agent matures, since mature agents may need larger, harder suites. Aim for roughly half everyday requests and half edge cases.
3. Isolate the Test Environment
Run every trial in the isolated environment you set up. Shared state between trials causes correlated failures and can inflate scores. In Anthropic's internal evals, Claude once gained an edge by reading git history left over from earlier trials.
With the model version and sampling settings pinned, a score change traces back to your edit.
4. Layer Your Graders
Anthropic names three grader types: code-based, model-based, and human. Use code checks wherever they apply, an LLM judge where they don't, and human review to calibrate that judge before you trust it.
Code checks handle anything objective, like "the booking API was called" or "the output is valid JSON."
5. Run Every Case Multiple Times
One passing run tells you little about a non-deterministic model. Anthropic runs the numbers: with a 75% per-trial success rate, the probability of passing all 3 trials is about 42%.
On the speech-to-speech benchmark (82 scenarios, three runs each, last updated 3 Nov), Gemini 3.8 Live passed 69.1% of individual calls but all three runs of a scenario only 41.5% of the time.
Two measures capture this. pass@k counts a case as passed if at least one of k runs succeeds, and pass^k requires every run to succeed. Report pass^k for anything a customer touches (pass@k suits tools where one working answer is enough).
6. Attack the Model
Run the red-team suite before you look at release scores. Cover the attack types from method five, and include multi-turn attacks for any conversational model.
7. Compare Against the Baseline and Gate the Release
Put the new scores next to the last release, test by test. A change that fixes one scenario can break another, and a side-by-side view is where that shows up.
Then make the CI gate from method six a required check, so a failing test blocks the merge.
8. Sign Off and Switch On Monitoring
Sign-off needs three things: every threshold from step one met, no open high-severity red-team finding, and a named owner who approves the release. The suite then keeps running against live traffic.
Metrics: How to Test the Accuracy of an AI Model
To test the accuracy of an AI model, score its outputs against known-correct answers. Which metric counts as accuracy depends on the output. Accuracy as a metric works for classifiers only; regression models need error measures, and LLMs need a pass rate against your graders.
| Metric | What it measures | Use it for |
|---|---|---|
| Accuracy | Correct predictions ÷ all predictions | Balanced classification |
| Precision | True positives ÷ everything flagged positive | Cases where false alarms cost you |
| Recall | True positives ÷ all actual positives | Cases where misses cost you |
| F1 | Harmonic mean of precision and recall | Imbalanced classification |
| MAE and RMSE | Average size of the error, with RMSE weighting large misses more | Regression models |
| R² | Share of variance in the target the model explains | Regression models |
| Task completion rate | Share of runs that reach the user's goal | Agents |
| Unsupported claim rate | Share of answers with factual claims the reference material doesn't back | LLMs and agents |
| Latency (P50, P95, P99) | Response time across the distribution | Any model that answers live |
| Cost per task | Model and tool spend ÷ completed tasks, including tokens used | LLMs and agents |
| Word error rate | (Substitutions + deletions + insertions) ÷ words in the reference transcript | Voice agents |
Accuracy breaks down when one class is rare. In Google's ML course example, when 1% of cases are positive, a model that predicts negative every time scores 99% accuracy "despite being useless."
Precision and recall expose that model right away: recall drops to zero.
Unsupported claim rate needs a source of truth. Without the knowledge base or reference documents loaded into the test, a grader can't tell an invented fact from a sourced one. A claim missing from your documents can still be true, so review a sample before you call every flag a hallucination.
Report latency as percentiles, since an average hides the slow tail that users feel as delay.
Testing AI Models in Production: Monitoring and Drift
A model that passed last month can fail today with no code change. The NIST AI Risk Management Framework, a voluntary framework, says AI systems "should be tested before their deployment and regularly while in operation."
Drift looks different for each model type:
-
Traditional ML models: Production inputs move away from the training data. Compare input distributions and per-slice metrics over time.
-
LLMs and agents: The provider updates the model, someone edits the prompt, or the knowledge base changes. Rerun the regression suite on each of those events.
Grade production traffic against the criteria your pre-release suite uses. When the two pass rates drift apart, your test set has usually stopped representing your users.
Feed production back into testing by adding every production failure to the regression suite, so the next run catches that bug if it comes back.
How to Test AI Agents and Voice Agents
To test an AI agent, run simulated multi-turn conversations against it and grade the whole transcript. Single-turn checks don't reach the moment a user changes their mind, where agents tend to break.
Here's an illustrative example in Cekura for a clinic scheduling agent. The caller books Tuesday at 3 PM, then switches to Wednesday morning mid-call.
In our docs, a test case is called an evaluator. Each evaluator has five parts:
-
Instructions: The caller asks for Tuesday at 3 PM, waits for confirmation, then asks for Wednesday morning. New workspaces write this as Structured Tests by default, where conditions set what the caller says after each agent move.
-
Expected outcome: One appointment exists on Wednesday morning. The result is scored as met or unmet.
-
Personality: A calm caller in a quiet room for the first run. The personality sets language, voice, background noise, interruption patterns, and speaking pace.
-
Metrics: Expected Outcome, Tool Call Success, Hallucination (checked against the agent's knowledge base files), and Latency, all from the pre-defined list.
-
Test profile (optional): The caller's name and date of birth, so the agent can find the patient record.
Run the scenario in text first. Chat Testing swaps phone calls for text, which Cekura’s docs describe as faster and cheaper than voice runs (10x faster and 90% cheaper, by our numbers).
Chatbots get tested the same way, with no voice layer to add later.
Then run it by voice. Save voice testing for speech recognition and text-to-speech checks and for final production checks.
Repeat each scenario three to five times, the frequency the A/B testing docs suggest. Then change the personality to an interrupting caller or one with background noise, and run it again.
Red-team the agent once the scenario suite passes, before you sign off. Cekura's multi-turn red teaming runs adversarial conversations of five to ten turns across six attack categories and scores each from 1 to 5. A score of 1 or 2 counts as a successful defense.
AI Model Testing Tools by Category
Tools for AI model testing fall into 4 groups. Plan on one from each. If you can only start with one, pick an open-source framework wired into CI. A platform pays off once several people need to review the same results.
| Category | Examples | Use it for |
|---|---|---|
| Open-source frameworks | Promptfoo, DeepEval, Inspect, OpenAI Evals, Ragas, Evidently, Deepchecks | Suites you run locally or in CI |
| Eval platforms | LangSmith, Braintrust, Langfuse, Phoenix, Cekura | Shared datasets, scoring, and production monitoring |
| Playgrounds | Google AI Studio, Phoenix prompt playground | Trying prompts and models side by side |
| Conversational agent simulation | Cekura | Simulated voice and chat conversations, scored before launch and on production calls |
Open-source frameworks run your test cases from code. Promptfoo is a CLI and library for evaluating and red-teaming LLM apps, and its repo states it's now part of OpenAI while staying MIT-licensed. Inspect comes from the UK AI Security Institute.
Evidently's library covers both ML and LLM systems. Deepchecks' package targets tabular, NLP, and computer vision validation under AGPL 3.0.
Eval platforms store datasets, run graders, and score live traffic. LangSmith splits its evaluations into offline tests on curated datasets and online scoring of live user interactions. Cekura is made for conversational AI agents and runs the simulated conversations itself.
Langfuse is self-hostable, with its core under MIT and enterprise features under a separate license. Phoenix comes from Arize AI and its contributor community and ships under the Elastic License 2.0.
Playgrounds are for exploring. Move any prompt you plan to ship into a suite first, because a playground run doesn't leave a pass condition behind.
Common Mistakes When Testing AI Models
Five mistakes show up again and again:
-
Running each case once: A single pass on a non-deterministic model is one sample. Run three to five trials and report how many passed.
-
Testing only the happy path: Users interrupt, correct themselves, and go off script. Half your suite should be edge cases.
-
Trusting an unchecked judge: Grade a sample by hand first, then measure how often the judge agrees with you.
-
Letting test data leak: For ML models, fit preprocessing on training data only. For LLMs, stop tuning prompts against the same cases you report scores on.
-
Keeping a suite that always passes: A suite at 100% still tracks regressions, but it can't show you improvement. Add harder cases.
How Cekura Tests the Voice and Chat Agents Running on Your AI Models
Everything above covers how to test AI models in isolation. Cekura tests the layer above them, whether the agent running on the model completes a full conversation, with simulations before launch and production monitoring after.
Pre-production:
-
Evaluators and personalities: Simulated callers and chat users run your scenarios, each with a defined personality and expected outcome. Traits that last the whole call, like accent or pace, live on the personality and can't be overridden by an evaluator's instructions.
-
A/B Testing: Two runs of the same evaluators sit side by side, with a breakdown of every metric across both versions.
-
CI gating: Once you add the workflow file, the GitHub Action runs your scenarios on the triggers you set, such as a push or pull request, and passes only when every run passes.
-
Red teaming: Multi-turn adversarial scenarios probe for system prompt leaks, data leaks, and unauthorized actions. In voice mode, each attack is generated once, without the optimization cycles text mode runs.
Infrastructure:
- Infrastructure Suite: 18+ ready-made scenarios check latency, stability, and failure handling.
Observability:
-
LLM Judge metrics: You describe success in plain language, and the judge scores production calls against it.
-
Metric Lab: Annotate a sample of calls with the correct values, and Auto Improve tunes the metric to match your labels. You review each proposed change before you accept it.
-
Improve Agent (beta): Takes failing calls or evaluators, changes the instructions on a private copy of your agent, and re-tests until it passes. You accept or discard the result.
Cekura supports SOC 2, HIPAA, and GDPR compliance, covering transcript redaction, role-based access, and audit trails.
Cekura connects natively to Retell, Vapi, ElevenLabs, LiveKit, Pipecat, Bland, and others. You add a testing and monitoring layer on top of the stack you already run.
The Startup plan costs $500/month, billed month to month, and includes about 2,000 minutes of voice testing and up to 10,000 monitored calls. Pay as you go has no monthly fee for the first user ($30/month per extra seat) and bills $0.25 per voice testing minute and $0.05 per monitored call.
Chat testing costs $0.025 per reply on pay-as-you-go.
New accounts start with 300 free credits, about 60 minutes of voice testing, with no card required. PII redaction costs 0.1 credits per minute and draws from the same credits. Enterprise pricing is custom, on annual contracts.
Book a demo to run a scenario suite against your own agent.
Frequently Asked Questions
How Do You Test the Accuracy of an AI Model?
You test the accuracy of an AI model by running it on inputs with known correct answers and scoring the outputs with a metric that matches the task.
Classifiers use accuracy, precision, and recall, while regression models use MAE or RMSE. LLMs need a pass rate, scored by assertions, a calibrated judge, or human review.
How Can I Test an AI Agent?
You can test an AI agent by running simulated multi-turn conversations and grading the full transcript, including each tool call. Run every scenario 3 to 5 times, then add adversarial scenarios.
What Is the Difference Between Testing an ML Model and Testing an LLM?
The main difference between testing an ML model and testing an LLM is how you decide an output is correct. An ML model's prediction is compared with a label. An LLM's output is graded by code checks, a judge model, or a human reviewer, across repeated runs.
How Many Test Cases Do You Need to Test an AI Model?
For a first evaluation suite, 20 to 50 test cases drawn from past failures is enough to start. Add one each time something breaks in production, and expect a mature agent to need more.
How Long Does It Take to Set Up AI Model Testing?
For an AI agent, setup takes about a day for a first usable run with the open-source agentevals trajectory evaluator, per our agent evals guide, and about 2 weeks for custom rubrics. Those are estimates, and your stack changes them.
Can Cekura Test AI Models?
Yes, Cekura tests the conversational AI agents that run on AI models, using simulated conversations before launch and scoring on production calls after. It doesn't validate traditional ML models like classifiers, where an open-source framework is the better choice.
